Wines & Vines Home
Welcome Guest

Gallo Winery Gets AVA Expansion

Russian River winemaker laments diluted appellation authenticity

by Jane Firstenfeld
merry edwards
Vintner Merry Edwards is confident that her brand will continue to thrive, but believes value of the Russian River Valley AVA is weakened by the recent TTV expansion.
Sebastopol, Calif.—All it took was “Money and time,” said winemaker Merry Edwards, describing the denouement of her lengthy and ultimately unsuccessful fight to prevent expansion of the Russian River Valley viticultural area. “I didn’t call you back before because it was too depressing.”

After years of regulatory wrangling, mega-producer E. & J. Gallo Winery eventually emerged victorious in its quest to enlarge the RRV AVA, in a decision announced by the Alcohol and Tobacco Trade Bureau (TTB) on Nov. 16, 2011, effective Dec. 16.  As requested in the petition from Gallo Family Vineyards, the ruling expands the RRV AVA by 14,044 acres and the overlapping Northern Sonoma AVA by 44,244 acres. The AVA now covers parts of what most locals might consider Central/Southern Sonoma or the Petaluma Gap.

“All you have to understand is that Gallo had been trying to do this since before 1993,” Edwards said last week. Edwards, owner of Merry Edwards Winery, had spoken to Wines & Vines regarding Gallo’s controversial petition to enlarge the AVA in 2008, when she led opposition from area winegrowers under the ad hoc Russian River Valley Boundary Integrity Coalition (RRVIC).

Established in 1983, the RRV AVA was previously expanded by 30,200 acres in 2005, in response to another Gallo-backed petition. The Russian River Valley Winegrowers had supported that redefinition of AVA boundaries.

“I was the bad girl. I withdrew from the board,” Edwards recalled last week. Of the larger wineries in the area, she said, “A lot of people do business with Gallo.” She speculated that motivated support for the company’s position.

When the TTB announced the most recent proposed rulemaking during the 2008 crush, Edwards quickly allied with other local growers and winemakers to form the RRVIC, which requested and obtained an extension of the abbreviated public comment period.

Then, Edwards said, “whole companies threw their staff into the research TTB wanted” to counter Gallo’s arguments favoring the expansion. Public comments, mostly adverse, poured in, reaching an impressive total of 171.

In its rulemaking, TTB broke these down as follows: 26 in support, 133 in opposition, and 12 others. Of the 26 supporting comments, 20 were from area grapegrowers, the balance from “the petitioner and its two consultants; Constellation Brands Inc., and Allied Grape Growers.” 

Opponents included 78 area grapegrowers and wineries, plus consumers, wine professionals, and the membership of the RRVW, although the RRVW board had remained neutral.

Insufficient evidence
Edwards said she was “flabbergasted” that in the end, the TTB not only discounted a 50-page document that RRVIC submitted to counter the petition but also “refused to acknowledge the influential people involved with it.

“We requested a flyover,” Edwards recalled. “They didn’t do that,” nor did TTB assign any bureau representatives actually to visit the vast and varied area.

“We objected and asked them to come here,” but, Edwards said, “Everything’s occurring in D.C.,” a bureaucratic limitation she termed “highly flawed.” “If the work we did was not enough, there is no recourse.”

Thomas Hogue, congressional and acting media representative for the TTB, told Wines & Vines that the bureau bases its rulemaking on the substance of the comments and documentation submitted. “It isn’t the who, it’s the what” that matters in evaluating the decisions, he said.

The lengthy and costly process of obtaining or altering an AVA requires multiple layers of review within the TTB and the Treasury Department and, he pointed out, the bureau works with petitioners prior to publishing pending rulings for mandated public comment.

“We want them to put their best foot forward,” he said. “We want it to be something that can work.”

According to the final ruling, TTB “noted that the assertions in the correspondence were not accompanied by any specific data that contradicted the petitioner’s submitted evidence.” Opponents, the bureau said, “are mostly vineyard or winery owners from the existing Russian River Valley viticultural area.”

Following the approval, Gallo chief viticulturist Jim Collins released a statement: “We are pleased to learn that the Treasury Department has decided to expand the Russian River Valley viticultural area. The expansion area shares with the original AVA the same coastal fog intrusion, climate, topography, soil and growing conditions which is why the expansion petition had broad support from local farmers, winery owners, consumers and agricultural organizations.”

Weakening the brand
“I was one of many people who made a public comment for the TTB…opposing the move. I don’t have a monetary stake in the issue; I’m just a wine lover, and specifically a Russian River Val ley wine lover,” wrote W. Blake Gray in his Gray Report of Nov. 21, “Gallo beats its neighbors and consumers, again.”

“The TTB deferred to Gallo and made a formerly great Sonoma County appellation less meaningful,” wrote the blogger and columnist.

With her winery’s firmly established reputation, Edwards said, “I have a good brand. I’ll be fine. I believe in the Russian River Valley, but if I were banking just on the area,” the future might be a little less secure, she acknowledged. In earlier days, she said, “Nobody wanted to be in the Russian River Valley AVA. Now everybody does. Trying to confuse people,” is what’s wrong with the system, Edwards said.

The TTB has posted numerous petitions and rulings in the past month. Wines & Vines will survey these in an upcoming Headline.

Currently no comments posted for this article.

Wines & Vines Home
866.453.9701 | 415.453.9700 | Fax: 415.453.2517
65 Mitchell Blvd., Ste. A San Rafael, CA 94903
Wine Industry Metrics
Off-Premise Sales
IRI Channels »
Month   12 Months  
October 2015 $604 million
$8,267 million
October 2014 $572 million $7,790 million
Direct-to-Consumer Shipments » Month   12 Months  
October 2015 $288 million
$1,919 million
October 2014 $284 million $1,751 million
Winery Job Index » Month   12 Months  
October 2015 179
October 2014 139 226
MORE » Released on 11.13.2015


Direct To Consumer
Wine Shipping Report
Download full report »


Practical Winery & Vineyard Library
Search the PWV archive »

  • December 2
    2015 UC Davis Grape Day
  • December 3
    North Coast Wine Industry Expo
  • December 5-6
    Holidays in the Vineyards
  • January 13-14
    DtC Wine Symposium
  • MORE »

Article: Kronenberg Leaves Legacy of DtC Opportunities »
This is amusing. While I do not quarrel with Paul's many contributions over the years,...
Reader: Guest
Article: Kronenberg Leaves Legacy of DtC Opportunities »
Wow! This this a re-writing of history! As a founder and namer of Family Winemakers...
Reader: Guest
Article: Can Wine Grapes Be Grown Without Chemicals? »
It sounds like your problem is with semantics, not with the application of products to...
Reader: Carol Collier
Article: Cuvaison Upgrades to Second Generation of Pellenc Sorter »
I'd like to know what they are doing with the sorted stuff, especially the first...
Reader: Matthew Delicata
Article: Growers Suffer Low Yields in Paso Robles »
This year's Paso Robles/San Miguel "mature" Cabernet Sauvignon yields were down to 30% of normal while...
Reader: Guest

2016 Directory/Buyer's Guide
The Wines & Vines Directory and Buyer's Guide
Wines & Vines Magazine
Digital Edition Now Available!
Wines & Vines Digital Edition Now Available
The Wines & Vines Online Marketing System
The Industry Standard winery marketing application
Latest Job Listings
 Referral Marketing Opp...
 Northeast, NA
Sales and Marketing
 Marketing & Communicat...
 Rutherford, CA
Sales and Marketing
 Assistant Tasting Room...
 Paso Robles, CA
DTC, Tasting Room and Retai
 Account Coordinator
 American Canyon, CA
General Administration and
 New World-Class Restau...
 Philo, CA
General Administration and
 Compliance Administrat...
 Healdsburg, CA
General Administration and
 Tasting Room Manager
 Santa Rosa, CA
DTC, Tasting Room and Retai
 Sales Representative
 Miami, Ft. Meyers/Naples, Tampa, FL
Sales and Marketing
 Area Sales Manager
 New York City (Metro), NY
Sales and Marketing
 Wine Adviser
 Norwalk, CT
Sales and Marketing
More Job Listings >>
Follow Us On:

Home  |  About Us  |  Editors  |  Subscribe  |  Print Edition  |  Digital Edition

Advertise  |  Site Map  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy
Copyright © 2001-2015 by Wine Communications Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
No material may be reproduced without written permission of the Publisher.
Wines&Vines does not assume any responsibility for any unsolicited manuscripts or materials.